Skip to content

All States  ›  New York  ›  Shirley

Heating Oil Prices in Shirley, NY

Real heating oil prices reported by homeowners in Shirley, NY

Shirley avg $4.68 per gallon
New York avg $5.87 state average
NE avg $5.58 Northeast avg
Local dealers 1 serving Shirley

The current heating oil price in Shirley, New York is $4.68 per gallon as of August 29, 2026. That's 90¢ below the Northeast average of $5.58/gal — one of the more affordable markets in the region.

Heating Oil Dealers in Shirley, NY

Prices may be dealer-entered, website-published, or administrator-reviewed. Call to confirm today's rate.

All New York dealers →
Dealer confidence:HighMediumLowHigh means verified identity plus a fresh supported dealer/first-party price; Medium means a verified dealer with unavailable, gated, stale, incomplete, or price-validation-pending data; Low means unresolved identity/evidence. Scraper health is tracked separately and does not by itself lower confidence. Questionable dealers are excluded from public results. This is not a customer rating or guarantee.
High Confidence
AI
All Island Fuel Transparent Pricing High Confidence 2 days old
82 Surrey Cir, Shirley, NY
$4.68 Updated 2 days ago
Delivery
631-281-7300 allislandfuel.com 💬 Report a price you paid here

Find the exact price at your address

Prices vary by zip code. Enter yours to see the most accurate local price.

Heating Oil Market Notes for Shirley, NY

Shirley is shown using New York regional heating-oil market data where a current dealer-specific price is not available. NYSERDA regional data is useful for comparison, but individual delivered prices can still vary by dealer, ZIP code, order size, and delivery timing.

The current public reference shown for Shirley, NY is $4.68 per gallon, and the New York benchmark is $5.87 per gallon, and the Northeast benchmark is $5.58 per gallon. This page shows an update date of August 29, 2026.

The page currently lists 1 heating-oil dealer serving Shirley. Review the dealer rows for price age, phone number, service area, and whether the dealer price is current before placing an order. Nearby tracked markets include Albany, Amsterdam, Arcade.

How to get the best heating oil price in Shirley

1
Compare at least 3 dealers

Prices between dealers in the same zip code can vary by 10–20¢ per gallon. On a 200-gallon fill that's $20–$40 saved from one phone call.

2
Buy in the off-season

Prices in Shirley are typically 15–25¢ lower between May and August when demand drops. Fill your tank before October.

3
Set a price alert

Use the alert form on this page and we'll email you when prices in Shirley drop to your target. Today's listed price is $4.68/gal.

4
Ask about budget plans

Many Shirley dealers offer 12-month budget plans that spread your annual heating cost evenly across every month — no surprise winter bills.