All States › New York › Middletown
Heating Oil Prices in Middletown, NY
Today's average heating oil price in Middletown is $5.53/gallon — 5¢ below the NE average of $5.58/gal. Updated May 5, 2026.
The current heating oil price in Middletown, New York is $5.53 per gallon as of May 5, 2026. That's 5¢ below the Northeast average of $5.58/gal — one of the more affordable markets in the region.
Heating oil dealers serving New York
No dealers listed specifically for Middletown yet. These dealers serve the broader New York area.
Find the exact price at your address
Prices vary by zip code. Enter yours to see the most accurate local price.
How to get the best heating oil price in Middletown
Prices between dealers in the same zip code can vary by 10–20¢ per gallon. On a 200-gallon fill that's $20–$40 saved from one phone call.
Prices in Middletown are typically 15–25¢ lower between May and August when demand drops. Fill your tank before October.
Use the alert form on this page and we'll email you the moment prices in Middletown drop to your target. Today's price is $5.53/gal.
Many Middletown dealers offer 12-month budget plans that spread your annual heating cost evenly across every month — no surprise winter bills.