Heating Oil Prices in Ithaca, NY

Today’s Heating Oil Price in Ithaca: $3.89/gal

At $3.89 per gallon, Ithaca heating oil is currently 2 cents below the Northeast average of $3.91. There are approximately 5 heating oil dealers actively serving the Ithaca area. Prices are updated every 24 hours.

Compare Heating Oil Dealers in Ithaca

The best way to find cheap heating oil in Ithaca is to compare at least 3 local dealers before placing an order. Prices between dealers in the same zip code can vary by 10–20 cents per gallon — on a 200-gallon fill that’s $20–$40 in savings just from making one phone call.

Heating Oil Prices in New York: How Ithaca Compares

The statewide average for New York is currently $3.84 per gallon. Prices in Ithaca reflect local dealer competition, delivery zone, and proximity to fuel terminals. Use our zip code tool to find the most accurate price for your specific neighborhood.

How to Get the Best Heating Oil Price in Ithaca

• Set a price alert: Enter your email above and we’ll notify you the moment prices in Ithaca drop to your target price.
• Buy in the off-season: Prices in Ithaca are typically 15–25 cents lower between May and August when demand is lowest.
• Ask about budget plans: Many Ithaca dealers offer 12-month budget plans to spread your annual heating cost evenly.
• Compare price cap contracts: Lock in a maximum price for next winter by signing a price cap contract in spring.
• Check minimum delivery: Some dealers require 100–150 gallon minimums. Confirm this before ordering.

Ithaca Heating Oil Price History

Heating oil prices in Ithaca have followed the Northeast trend closely over the past 12 months. After peaking in winter 2025, prices have eased through spring as seasonal demand dropped. The current price of $3.89/gal reflects March 2026 market conditions. Check back daily for the latest update or set a price alert to be notified automatically.

Find the exact price at your address

Prices vary by zip code. Enter yours to see the most accurate local price.